Header Logo राजस्थान लोक सेवा आयोग
ISO(2001:2008) राजस्थान सरकार

Rajasthan Public Service Commission
ISO(2001:2008) Govt. of Rajasthan
Header Logo
Header Logo

Important Court Judgment


S.No.Writ NoTitleSubjectOrder DateOrder in BriefLink
plus
Title
Prema Ram Patel & Ors v/s State & Ors
Subject
Answer Key
Order Date
22/03/2024
Order in Brief
There is a limited scope of Judicial Review in matters of examination for recruitment in public services. This should be exercised only when there is palpable and demonstrated error. The answer Key should be assumed to be correct unlees it is proved to be wrong and must be clearly demonstrated to be wrong.
1SBCWP No. 18130/23 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Prema Ram Patel & Ors v/s State & OrsAnswer Key22/03/2024There is a limited scope of Judicial Review in matters of examination for recruitment in public services. This should be exercised only when there is palpable and demonstrated error. The answer Key should be assumed to be correct unlees it is proved to be wrong and must be clearly demonstrated to be wrong.
plus
Title
Aditya Singh v/s RPSC & Ors
Subject
Result declared according to aggregate 40% minimum
Order Date
14/12/2023
Order in Brief
Petitioner is estopped from challenging the scheme of examination and the terms and conditions of the advertisement after having participated in the examination.
2SBCWP No 1044/20 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Aditya Singh v/s RPSC & OrsResult declared according to aggregate 40% minimum14/12/2023Petitioner is estopped from challenging the scheme of examination and the terms and conditions of the advertisement after having participated in the examination.
plus
Title
Babulal Sahu v/s State & Ors
Subject
Reservation Policy for Person with Disability (PWD
Order Date
12/12/2023
Order in Brief
Petitioner is estopped from challenging the scheme of examination and the terms and conditions of the advertisement after having participated in the examination.
3SBCWP no. 15251/19 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Babulal Sahu v/s State & OrsReservation Policy for Person with Disability (PWD12/12/2023Petitioner is estopped from challenging the scheme of examination and the terms and conditions of the advertisement after having participated in the examination.
plus
Title
Naresh Kumar v/s State & Ors
Subject
Cut off date for requisite qualification
Order Date
13/09/2023
Order in Brief
It is well within the domain of the employer to fix a cut off date for candidates to acquire education qualification to be eligible for participating in the recruitment process.
4SBCWP No. 7594/18 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Naresh Kumar v/s State & OrsCut off date for requisite qualification13/09/2023It is well within the domain of the employer to fix a cut off date for candidates to acquire education qualification to be eligible for participating in the recruitment process.
plus
Title
Ambika Nehra v/s State & Ors
Subject
Answer key/Evaluation of questions & Answers
Order Date
12/09/2023
Order in Brief
Petitioners challenged the answer key published by the RPSC. Since, three consecutive committees of the experts had examined almost all questions, the Court does not feel to interfere in the matter.(in the light of judgment of Vikesh Kumar Gupta)
5SBCWP no. 1785/21 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Ambika Nehra v/s State & OrsAnswer key/Evaluation of questions & Answers12/09/2023Petitioners challenged the answer key published by the RPSC. Since, three consecutive committees of the experts had examined almost all questions, the Court does not feel to interfere in the matter.(in the light of judgment of Vikesh Kumar Gupta)
plus
Title
Nand Kishore Chouhan v/s State & Ors
Subject
Experience regarding NGE
Order Date
04/09/2023
Order in Brief
Non Gazzeted employees and Departmental candidates are two different categories.
6SBCWP No. 5516/19 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Nand Kishore Chouhan v/s State & OrsExperience regarding NGE04/09/2023Non Gazzeted employees and Departmental candidates are two different categories.
plus
Title
Gaurav Sharma v/s State & Ors
Subject
Category Change
Order Date
29/08/2023
Order in Brief
The eligibility or candidature of a candidate has to be seen on the date of submitting the application form.
7SBCWP no. 6603/15 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Gaurav Sharma v/s State & OrsCategory Change29/08/2023The eligibility or candidature of a candidate has to be seen on the date of submitting the application form.
plus
Title
Bharat Nath Yogi v/s State & Ors
Subject
Scaling
Order Date
28/08/2023
Order in Brief
There is no illegality or irregularity in Commission’s approach in adopting process of normalisation.
8SBCWP no. 1437/16 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Bharat Nath Yogi v/s State & OrsScaling28/08/2023There is no illegality or irregularity in Commission’s approach in adopting process of normalisation.
plus
Title
Rajendra Kumar Sharma & Anr v/s State & Ors
Subject
Operation of reserve list
Order Date
25/08/2023
Order in Brief
The lifespan of reserve list subsists for a period of six months from the date, on which, the original list is forwarded by the Commission to the State/appointing authority.
9SBCWP no. 7978/22 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Rajendra Kumar Sharma & Anr v/s State & OrsOperation of reserve list25/08/2023The lifespan of reserve list subsists for a period of six months from the date, on which, the original list is forwarded by the Commission to the State/appointing authority.
plus
Title
Surjan Lal Dhawan & Ors v/s State & Ors
Subject
Answer Key
Order Date
25/08/2023
Order in Brief
Opinion of Experts can not be interfered by the Court. The answer Key should be assumed to be correct unlees it is proved to be wrong and must be clearly demonstrated to be wrong.
10SBCWP No. 4777/21 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Surjan Lal Dhawan & Ors v/s State & OrsAnswer Key25/08/2023Opinion of Experts can not be interfered by the Court. The answer Key should be assumed to be correct unlees it is proved to be wrong and must be clearly demonstrated to be wrong.
plus
Title
Kuldeep Singh & Anr v/s State & Ors
Subject
Cut off date for requisite qualification
Order Date
23/08/2023
Order in Brief
The petitioner's candidature not be treated as eligible as he was not acquiring the requisite educational qualification before or upto the cut off date, as fixed by the RPSC in advertisement.
11SBCWP No. 5773/23 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Kuldeep Singh & Anr v/s State & OrsCut off date for requisite qualification23/08/2023The petitioner's candidature not be treated as eligible as he was not acquiring the requisite educational qualification before or upto the cut off date, as fixed by the RPSC in advertisement.
plus
Title
Rohit Kaushik v/s State & Ors
Subject
Age Relaxation
Order Date
16/08/2023
Order in Brief
The benefit of age relaxation cannot be claimed as a matter of right.
12SBCWP No. 2735/13 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Rohit Kaushik v/s State & OrsAge Relaxation16/08/2023The benefit of age relaxation cannot be claimed as a matter of right.
plus
Title
Sanju Jainth v/s RPSC
Subject
Category change (SC/WE to SC/WE/DV)
Order Date
10/08/2023
Order in Brief
Once a candidate has filled form in a perticular category, he/she is not entitled to change the same. Category change can be permitted in those cases where the category sought to be changed has been aquired subsequently.
13SAW 1340/22 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Sanju Jainth v/s RPSCCategory change (SC/WE to SC/WE/DV)10/08/2023Once a candidate has filled form in a perticular category, he/she is not entitled to change the same. Category change can be permitted in those cases where the category sought to be changed has been aquired subsequently.
plus
Title
Mahipal Singh & Ors v/s State & Ors
Subject
Answer Key
Order Date
04/08/2023
Order in Brief
Expert committee has examined the matter then nothing is left out for interfence of the Court.
14SAW 252/21 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Mahipal Singh & Ors v/s State & OrsAnswer Key04/08/2023Expert committee has examined the matter then nothing is left out for interfence of the Court.
plus
Title
Mahesh Kumar v/s State & Ors
Subject
Questions out of syllabus
Order Date
19/07/2023
Order in Brief
Once experts have assessed the questions, Court can not sit to reassess the same.
15SAW 1064/22 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Mahesh Kumar v/s State & OrsQuestions out of syllabus19/07/2023Once experts have assessed the questions, Court can not sit to reassess the same.
plus
Title
RPSC v/s Sangeeta Varhat
Subject
Requirement to have divorce decree for claiming re
Order Date
10/11/2022
Order in Brief
Decree of divorce is a must for claiming reservation in recruitment, even in case of customary divorce amongst the members of Scheduled Tribe/Tribal Sub Plan Communities. A custom cannot to be allowed to supersede the terms and conditions governing the recruitment process.
16SAW 72/22 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)RPSC v/s Sangeeta VarhatRequirement to have divorce decree for claiming re10/11/2022Decree of divorce is a must for claiming reservation in recruitment, even in case of customary divorce amongst the members of Scheduled Tribe/Tribal Sub Plan Communities. A custom cannot to be allowed to supersede the terms and conditions governing the recruitment process.
plus
Title
Chain Singh Gurjar & Ors v/s RPSC
Subject
Accept offline application form
Order Date
28/07/2022
Order in Brief
No relief can be granted to a person who was negligent and did not fill the form in the prescribed/stipulated period. No illegality has been committed by the Commission in not extending the date for submitting the online application form.
17SBCWP No. 9139/22 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Chain Singh Gurjar & Ors v/s RPSCAccept offline application form28/07/2022No relief can be granted to a person who was negligent and did not fill the form in the prescribed/stipulated period. No illegality has been committed by the Commission in not extending the date for submitting the online application form.
plus
Title
Aditi Dadhich v/s State & Ors
Subject
Educational Qualification till last cut off date
Order Date
12/04/2022
Order in Brief
A Candidate must possess the requisite qualification as on the cut off date mentioned in the advertisement.
18SBCWP no. 4551/21 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Aditi Dadhich v/s State & OrsEducational Qualification till last cut off date12/04/2022A Candidate must possess the requisite qualification as on the cut off date mentioned in the advertisement.
plus
Title
RPSC v/s Yogita Yaduvanshi
Subject
Category change correction in online application f
Order Date
19/03/2021
Order in Brief
The online corrections could be made in the application form within the stipulated period, which is provided by the RPSC and not after that.
19SAW 804/20 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)RPSC v/s Yogita YaduvanshiCategory change correction in online application f19/03/2021The online corrections could be made in the application form within the stipulated period, which is provided by the RPSC and not after that.
plus
Title
RPSC v/s Kavita Godara & Ors
Subject
Fixation of the number of candidates called for in
Order Date
02/03/2021
Order in Brief
The wisdom of Commission in calling the successful candidates for interview by fixing their number categorywise cannot be said to be illegal or unjustified and it is not in the domain of the Court to fix the number of candidates required to be called for interview.
20SAW 103/21 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)RPSC v/s Kavita Godara & OrsFixation of the number of candidates called for in02/03/2021The wisdom of Commission in calling the successful candidates for interview by fixing their number categorywise cannot be said to be illegal or unjustified and it is not in the domain of the Court to fix the number of candidates required to be called for interview.
plus
Title
Vikesh Kumar Gupta v/s State of Rajasthan
Subject
Answer Key
Order Date
07/12/2020
Order in Brief
It was held that Courts ought not interfere with the examination process as the Courts cannot be said to be expert body. Assessment of the questions by the Court itself to arrive at correct answers is not permissible.
21Civil Appeal No. 3649/20 (Sup. Court, New Delhi)Vikesh Kumar Gupta v/s State of RajasthanAnswer Key07/12/2020It was held that Courts ought not interfere with the examination process as the Courts cannot be said to be expert body. Assessment of the questions by the Court itself to arrive at correct answers is not permissible.
plus
Title
Mamta Sharma v/s RPSC & Anr
Subject
Reevaluation of Answer Scripts
Order Date
29/01/2020
Order in Brief
Courts cannot examine the question paper and answer sheets as it does not have expertise to do so and the Rules also prohibit re-examination of the answer sheets.
22SBCWP no. 14302/17 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Mamta Sharma v/s RPSC & AnrReevaluation of Answer Scripts29/01/2020Courts cannot examine the question paper and answer sheets as it does not have expertise to do so and the Rules also prohibit re-examination of the answer sheets.
plus
Title
Sonal Tyagi v/s State & Ors
Subject
Category Change
Order Date
12/07/2019
Order in Brief
If Category be allowed to change after declaration of result, then the persons who have availed reservation in that category may be ousted from the merit list and their interest may be prejudiced, so it is not allowed.
23DBCWP No. 7840/19 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Sonal Tyagi v/s State & OrsCategory Change12/07/2019If Category be allowed to change after declaration of result, then the persons who have availed reservation in that category may be ousted from the merit list and their interest may be prejudiced, so it is not allowed.
plus
Title
Shyam Sunder v/s State & Ors
Subject
Reevaluation
Order Date
22/04/2019
Order in Brief
Evaluation and deciphering answer to a subjective question always varies evaluator to evaluator and it cannot be alleged that the same shall remained static. It would neither be permissible nor just and proper to interfere and reevaluate the answer scripts.
24SAW 993/18 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Shyam Sunder v/s State & OrsReevaluation22/04/2019Evaluation and deciphering answer to a subjective question always varies evaluator to evaluator and it cannot be alleged that the same shall remained static. It would neither be permissible nor just and proper to interfere and reevaluate the answer scripts.
plus
Title
Piyush Kaviya & Ors v/s RPSC & Ors
Subject
Category Change consider in NGE
Order Date
10/04/2018
Order in Brief
Candidate cannot be allowed to change category after admit cards has been issued.
25SAW 198/18 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Piyush Kaviya & Ors v/s RPSC & OrsCategory Change consider in NGE10/04/2018Candidate cannot be allowed to change category after admit cards has been issued.
plus
Title
RPSC v/s Anil Kumar & Ors
Subject
Cut off date for requisite qualification
Order Date
03/11/2017
Order in Brief
A person taking to examination conducted by the Commission should have appeared or should be appearing in the final year examination of the course which is requisite educational qualification is that by the time the Commission conducts the examination.
26SAW 1693/17 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)RPSC v/s Anil Kumar & OrsCut off date for requisite qualification03/11/2017A person taking to examination conducted by the Commission should have appeared or should be appearing in the final year examination of the course which is requisite educational qualification is that by the time the Commission conducts the examination.
plus
Title
RPSC v/s Pankaj Raj & Ors
Subject
Answer Key
Order Date
08/05/2017
Order in Brief
The Court should not at all re-evaluate or scruitinize the answer sheets of a candidate, it has no expertise in the matter and academic matters are based left to academics.
27SAW 697/19 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)RPSC v/s Pankaj Raj & OrsAnswer Key08/05/2017The Court should not at all re-evaluate or scruitinize the answer sheets of a candidate, it has no expertise in the matter and academic matters are based left to academics.
plus
Title
Satish Kumar Sharma v/s RPSC
Subject
Change of Category
Order Date
08/02/2017
Order in Brief
Candidates cannot be allowed to change category after declaration of result. A candidate having appeared and participated in the selection process cannot turn around and challenge the same after he was declared unsucsessful.
28SBCWP No. 7673/16 (Raj. High Court, Jodhpur)Satish Kumar Sharma v/s RPSCChange of Category08/02/2017Candidates cannot be allowed to change category after declaration of result. A candidate having appeared and participated in the selection process cannot turn around and challenge the same after he was declared unsucsessful.
plus
Title
Shweta Khaiwal v/s State & Ors
Subject
Educational Qualification upto cut off date
Order Date
19/05/2016
Order in Brief
The petitioners were not in possession of the required essential qualifications in terms of the advertisement before the cut off date. Hence are not eligible to be considered.
29SBCWP No. 12836/14 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Shweta Khaiwal v/s State & OrsEducational Qualification upto cut off date19/05/2016The petitioners were not in possession of the required essential qualifications in terms of the advertisement before the cut off date. Hence are not eligible to be considered.
plus
Title
Mukesh Kumari v/s RPSC
Subject
To show answer booklet of main exam
Order Date
15/05/2014
Order in Brief
The scheme of examination consist of two phases, preliminary and main examination. Main examination comprises of both written examination as well as personality and viva-voce xamination. Unless all these stage are over, the process of examination cannot to be said to be complete and disclosure of information (answer booklet) is not permissible, the petitioner can request after the declaration of final result is over.
30SBCWP no. 2032/14 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Mukesh Kumari v/s RPSCTo show answer booklet of main exam15/05/2014The scheme of examination consist of two phases, preliminary and main examination. Main examination comprises of both written examination as well as personality and viva-voce xamination. Unless all these stage are over, the process of examination cannot to be said to be complete and disclosure of information (answer booklet) is not permissible, the petitioner can request after the declaration of final result is over.
plus
Title
Shanu Goyal v/s State & Ors
Subject
Disclosure of information under RTI
Order Date
08/07/2013
Order in Brief
Disclosure of information under RTI when the recruitment process is ongoing would undermine confidentiality. Hence, information can not be given when the process is still ongoing.
31DBCWP no. 11708/13 (Raj. High Court, Jaipur)Shanu Goyal v/s State & OrsDisclosure of information under RTI08/07/2013Disclosure of information under RTI when the recruitment process is ongoing would undermine confidentiality. Hence, information can not be given when the process is still ongoing.
India Portal
State Portal
National Voters Services Portal
Marking 150th birth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi
Call 1064 in case of Bribe Ask
Visitor Number: 12,02,19,500
Last Updated on: Jun 24, 2024